The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has launched an investigation into potential malfunctions of Tesla electronic door handles—specifically on the 2021 Model Y—after receiving reports that people were unable to open the doors and retrieve children from the back seat. The probe covers an estimated 174,290 vehicles in the U.S.
In several cases, parents say they stepped out briefly—either to strap in a child before starting a drive or to take a child out after a trip—and then couldn’t reopen the doors. Four owners reported smashing a window to regain access. In hot weather or emergencies, every second counts.
Key takeaways
- Who’s investigating: NHTSA’s Office of Defects Investigation (ODI)
- What’s under the microscope: Electronic door handle operation on 2021 Tesla Model Y
- Reported incidents: 9 owner complaints (VOQs) where doors couldn’t be reopened from outside
- Serious outcomes: 4 cases required breaking a window to reach a child
- Core concern: If power is lost, exterior access can be difficult; interior manual releases may not be reachable by a child
- Scope: About 174,290 Model Y vehicles (2021 model year) in the U.S.
- What started it: NHTSA’s inquiry follows a broader Bloomberg report on electronic door handles across the auto industry
At a glance: what NHTSA is looking at
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Vehicle(s) | 2021 Tesla Model Y |
| Issue | Inability to open doors from outside, reportedly after a drive cycle or before startup |
| Reports (VOQs) | 9 owner complaints; 4 involved breaking a window |
| Safety risk | Entrapment, especially dangerous for children and in hot weather |
| Design factors | Frameless doors, electronic unlatching, window “drop” sequence |
| Backup | Manual interior releases exist but may be hard to find or unreachable for kids |
| 12‑volt angle | Reported low/failed 12‑volt batteries with no warning; exterior “jump” process is complex |
| Population | ~174,290 vehicles (US) |
| Status | NHTSA investigation opened (data-gathering phase) |
- Tesla uses frameless doors and electronic handles. Pressing the handle/button drops the window slightly, then electronically unlatches the door so it can swing open.
- If the electronic system doesn’t wake or the 12‑volt battery is weak/failed—especially after a crash or while the vehicle is “asleep”—the exterior latch may not function as expected.
- There are mechanical releases inside the cabin, but owners and first responders have noted they can be hard to locate if you haven’t practiced—and a child strapped into a seat may not be able to reach or operate them.
ODI says the most common scenarios involve a parent stepping out briefly—either after a drive to take a child out of the back seat, or before starting the drive to put a child in. When they tried to reopen a door, it wouldn’t. In four cases, parents broke a window to get back in. The agency flags a particular worry: children trapped inside a vehicle, especially in heat, where risk escalates quickly. NHTSA also notes it runs a Child Heatstroke Campaign to raise awareness about these dangers.
According to reports cited by NHTSA, Tesla service replaced 12‑volt batteries in some affected vehicles. The agency’s concern is twofold:
- Lack of warning: Owners allegedly didn’t receive adequate notice that the 12‑volt battery was about to fail.
- Complex workaround: Tesla’s owner’s manual outlines a multi‑step process to restore power from outside by applying 12 volts at two different exterior points (under “Jump Starting” and “Opening the Hood with No Power”). NHTSA believes most owners don’t know this process—and even if they did, it may be too complicated to carry out in a stressful moment.
Electronic Handles vs. emergencies
- Pros: Clean design, aero gains, and a smooth user experience when everything’s powered up.
- Cons: In a power-loss scenario, exterior access can be tricky; interior manual releases require familiarity.
- Real-world stakes: In hot weather, interior temperatures can spike fast. Entrapment—even for a few minutes—poses serious risks to children and pets.
Opening an investigation is step one. NHTSA will gather data from owners and Tesla, analyze the frequency and root causes, and assess risk. Depending on findings, outcomes could range from no action, to service bulletins, software/hardware changes, or a recall. The company reportedly replaced 12‑volt batteries in some cases. Broader warnings, software tweaks, or hardware updates could be on the table pending NHTSA’s review.
Take five minutes to find and practice the interior emergency door releases for each door. Show other caregivers, too. If you notice quirky lock behavior, slow wake‑ups, or accessory glitches, schedule service. Ask about 12‑volt health checks. Keep the owner’s manual (digital or paper) handy, and know where the “Opening the Hood with No Power” and “Jump Starting” sections live. If someone is trapped and you can’t gain entry fast, call 911. Breaking a window is a last resort—but seconds matter in heat. If you’ve experienced similar problems, submit a complaint to NHTSA (safercar.gov or NHTSA app). More data speeds up solutions.
- Frameless, power‑assisted doors rely on a window “drop” and electronic unlatch—great when powered, fragile when not.
- Interior mechanical releases help—but must be easy to find, intuitive, and reachable. That’s a key human‑factors challenge NHTSA appears to be weighing.
Electronic door handles aren’t unique to Tesla. A recent Bloomberg report spotlighted how widespread they’ve become—and the pitfalls when power or software acts up. Tesla is in the hot seat here partly because it leans heavily on electronic actuation across the lineup and has a large fleet on the road.
NHTSA is scrutinizing whether the 2021 Tesla Model Y’s electronic door systems—and the backup procedures when power is lost—put occupants at risk, particularly children. The agency’s early read: nine complaints, four broken windows, and real concerns about hot‑car entrapment and 12‑volt battery warning visibility. For owners, a little preparation goes a long way: learn the manual releases, watch for low‑power symptoms, and know what to do when seconds count. For Tesla, the next steps may involve clearer alerts, simpler emergency access, and user‑friendlier guidance if power goes down.
Related Post